Skip to main content Matas Library Subject Guides Rudolph Matas Health Sciences Library Tulane University | Howard-Tilton Memorial Library's Homepage Tulane University Homepage

Forensic Psychiatry Research Guide

A Matas Library Subject Guide to support the Tulane Forensic Fellowship Program.

Forensic Psychiatry

Ethics

Stahl's Essential Psychopharmacology Online

Stahls logo

Psychiatry Online

psychiatryonline logo

APA Position Statement on insanity defense

The insanity defense1 is deeply rooted in Anglo-American law. Although the specific standard by which legal insanity is determined has varied over time and across jurisdictions, the insanity defense has always been grounded in the belief that there are defendants whose mental conditions are so impaired at the time of the crime that it would be unfair to punish them for their acts.

Recognizing that the insanity defense plays a critical role in the administration of criminal justice in the United States, the American Psychiatric Association endorses the following positions:

1) Serious mental disorders2 can substantially impair an individual’s capacities to reason rationally and to inhibit behavior that violates the law. The APA strongly supports the insanity defense because it offers our criminal justice system a mechanism for recognizing the unfairness of punishing persons who exhibit substantial impairment of mental function at the time of their actions.

2) The APA does not favor any particular legal standard for the insanity defense over another, so long as the standard is broad enough to allow meaningful consideration of the impact of serious mental disorders on individual culpability.
______________________
1By the term “insanity defense,” we include verdicts of “not guilty by reason of insanity,” “guilty but not criminally responsible,” and related formulations.
2“Serious mental disorder” is meant to encompass not only major psychiatric disorders, but also developmental disabilities and other causes of impaired mental function (e.g., severe head trauma) that otherwise meet the legal criteria for the insanity defense.

 

Forensic Medicine

Selected Library Books (In Print)

  • Principles and practice of forensic psychiatry / edited by Richard Rosner. Oxford University Press, c2003. W 740 P954.2 2003
  • Principles and practice of geriatric psychiatry / edited by Marc E. Agronin, Gabe J. Maletta. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, c2006.
    WT 150 P9575 2006
  • Adolescent forensic psychiatry / edited by Susan Bailey and Mairead Dolan. Oxford University Press, 2004. WS 463 Ad239 2004
  • Principles and practice of child and adolescent forensic psychiatry / edited by Diane H. Schetky, Elissa P. Benedek. American Psychiatric Pub., c2002. W 740 P957 2002
  • Forensic pathology in criminal cases / Michael Graham, Randy Hanzlick.
    Lexis, 2006. W 700 G741.3 2006
  • The American Psychiatric Publishing textbook of forensic psychiatry / edited by Robert I. Simon, Liza H. Gold. American Psychiatric Pub., c2004. W 740 Am5127 2004
  • Forensic psychiatry: influences of evil / edited by Tom Mason.
    Humana Press, c2006. W 740 F713 2006